Recap: VILLARREAL 1-1 MANCHESTER UNITED (VILLARREAL WIN 11-10 ON PENALTIES)

MISS! Rulli makes the stop, producing a diving low save to palm his effort away from goal. It was a tame strike from the Spaniard and the Villarreal keeper guessed the right way.

Rulli smashes his effort past his opposite number into the top-right corner. 11-10.

Lindelof sends the shootout to a duel between the keepers. His effort bursts through the hands of Rulli into the top-right corner. 10-10.

Torres scores a stunner from the spot, placing a strike into the top-left corner. De Gea has no chance. 10-9.

Calm and composed from Tuanzebe as he places his effort into the top-right corner. 9-9.

Gaspar goes high into the net with a powerful right-footed drive. 9-8.

Shaw steps forward and the ball squirms past Rulli, who should make the stop but he cannot produce a firm hand when he needs it the most. 8-8.

Coquelin produces a fine strike, firing his effort high into the roof of the net. A great penalty. 8-7.

James holds his nerve as he goes high into the top-right corner, sending Rulli the wrong way. 7-7.

Cool as you like from Albiol as he places his effort into the bottom-right corner. 7-6.

Rulli guesses the right way, but Fred beats the keeper for power with an effort into the bottom-right corner. 6-6.

Gomez dispatches his effort straight down the middle of the net. 6-5.

Cavani has to score for United and does not disappoint. He sends Rulli the wrong way and with a firm effort into the left side of the net. 5-5.

Parejo holds his nerve with a fine strike away from De Gea. United have to score the next kick to keep the shootout going. 5-4.

Rashford takes a stutter-step run and places a composed effort into the left side of the net. 4-4.

Moreno breaks the trend of the shootout and goes for power to the right side of the net. He beats De Gea with a strike into the bottom-right corner.

United's usual penalty taker Fernandes steps forward and maintains the rate of success. Rulli gets a hand to the ball, but the power of the effort sees it travel into the bottom-left corner. 3-3.

Alcacer just beats the hand of De Gea with his low strike. The United keeper gets a hand to the ball, but cannot keep it out. 3-2.

Telles takes a stutter-step run before hammering a left-footed strike into the bottom-left corner. 2-2.

Raba holds his nerve from the spot, placing his effort down the middle of the goal. 2-1.

Mata responds for United with his first kick of the game, placing his effort high into the top-left corner. 1-1.

Gerard sends De Gea the wrong way and slots his left-footed strike into the bottom-left corner. 1-0.

Gerard will be first up for Villarreal from the spot.

Both sides lacked conviction in the final third to find a winner in extra-time. The Europa League crown will be decided on penalties.

FULL-TIME EXTRA-TIME: VILLARREAL 1-1 MANCHESTER UNITED - Recaps